7 Best Benefit Erase Paste Dupes – Review And Buying Guide

If you are a makeup junkie, then you know the hype of concealer dupes that made people crazy right after they were introduced. They are designed to camouflage the underneath dark circles to brighten eyelids. Lately, I encountered the query Best Benefit Erase Paste Dupes on the social platform. 

To find out what is best and more alike to the original one, I searched and bought one that has almost the same texture and staying power. Moreover, that provides my face skin with full coverage.

In this article, I will demonstrate the 7 Best Benefit Erase Paste Dupes that you choose and get a flawless look as good as the original one. Also, I will describe our top recommendations and buying guide so you can easily opt according to your choice.

Our Top Recommendations

There are numerous makeup dupes in the market, but not all are worth buying and applying over the skin. Below, I am sharing our top recommendations that I use and that contain lovely ingredients for your skin.

  • NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Dark Circle Concealer – best for dark circles
  • Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer Stick – best for hydrating and minimizing imperfections
  • Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser – best for hydrates, concealing, and contours

Review of best Concealer Dupes

I searched and then bought the concealer dupes, knowing how they are effective on my skin and in what ways they could harm my skin. I have used the following dupes I will share with you for an extended period, and they were super fab over my skin without making it worse.

Original Product: Benefit Erase Paste

Unboxing: I ordered the best and most long-lasting Benefit Erase Paste after reading all the good comments on social mediaThe product came with an instruction card and a scoop to take out the paste upon unboxing.

I applied it using a brush because a damp sponge absorbs some of the product and will lose coverage and be less than medium coverage. Applied it underneath my eyes, and it smoothly blended out. The creamy texture helped the concealer to set into my skin flawlessly. I bake it with a translucent powder, so it does not accentuate my fine line.

Wearing it for 6-7 hours, and when I saw myself in the mirror, there were little cracks within the products. Although it brightened up my underneath area and lid, it spread over my skin and creased a bit at the corner. It needs to be touched up almost after every 6 hours so that it sets on the skin without settling into fine lines.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: creamy
  • Coverage: full
  • Skin type: all
  • Age range: adult
  • Package information: pot


  • The texture is creamy.
  • Super pigmented and little goes a long way.
  • It brightens the eyes and works excellently in hiding blemishes and dark circles.


  • It did not build up and look cakey when applied more.
  • The price is high.

Final Verdict

The product goes a little long for me, but it still brightens my skin. The consistency was terrific, and melts into the skin smoothly. It is not wearing to my liking as it needs retouching, but if you have to wear it for a short time, you opt for this product to get outstanding coverage.

Do you want to learn how to make concealer at home? Learn here: How to make makeup concealer at home?

Revlon PhotoReady Candid Concealer

Unboxing: People are raving about this product, and let’s give Revlon PhotoReady Candid Concealer a try. I ordered and received my parcel. The packaging and sealing were good. I took out the concealer and tried it over my prime face.

It came in tube packaging along with a flexible doe foot applicator for precise application. I started with the inner eye area and then worked my way out. The concealer woke up my skin as it was infused with caffeine.

I noticed that it translates into a very nice formula that did not break. Moreover, the texture needed to be more matte to not settle into my lines. The concealer did not look heavy and overly on top of that; it brightened my eyes, even though it had medium coverage.

I wore it for an insane 9 hours and did not remember it faded much from when I initially applied. 

This concealer is formulated without oils, phthalates, parabens, synthetic dyes, or fragrances.

Revlon ColorStay Concealer seemed appealing, so I thought to give it a chance. It provided my skin with a flawless look and matte finish. But the thing I did not like about the product was it settled into my fine line. Moreover, I felt a similar white cast left on my face while capturing the photo with a camera flash.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: creamy
  • Coverage: medium
  • Finishing: natural matte
  • Skin type: sensitive skin
  • Package Information: tube (doe foot applicator)


  • It works amazingly in blurring the under-eye bags and severe hereditary dark circles.
  • The concealer contains antioxidants, anti-pollution, and anti-blue light that are best for the skin.
  • Provide medium coverage but can be built up for high.
See also  Do Spray Tans Cover Stretch Marks? [Step-by-Step Guide]


  • I found the consistency thick.
  • Take time while blending.

Final Verdict

This Revlon concealer is infused with caffeine that helps the product to build up. Moreover, it gives skin a natural matte finish that everyone loves.

Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer Makeup

Unboxing: As I surfed for a liquid concealer, my eyes suddenly got on Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer. Without wasting any time, I ordered and received my package. It came in a slim thick bottle along with a doe foot applicator. 

As it claims to blur the dark circles and spots, I applied concealer under my eyes and over my blemishes and dark spots. It was easily blended while providing skin a natural coverage which means it is not a full coverage concealer. 

I wore it for 8 hours to check how long it went. The concealer looks dry and accentuated in lines and creases underneath my eyes. However, it did well without getting cakey over my blemishes and dark spots.

The consistency of the concealer was liquid and did not feel heavy on my skin. It left my skin breathable. Moreover, It wore off here and there and looked smooth as it did in the beginning. 

It is proven non-comedogenic, which means it does not clog pores. Additionally, it is tested by a dermatologist and is fragrance-free and oil-free.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: liquid
  • Coverage: medium
  • Finishing: sheer to natural
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: slim bottle (doe foot applicator)


  • This lightweight, buildable concealer gives skin a natural finish.
  • It covers my blemishes and dark spots.
  • It is half of the fraction.


  • It stung when I applied it.
  • The product looks cakey and patchy after some hours.

Final Verdict

The Maybelline liquid concealer was great when I applied it, but it settled into the lines and looked weird. This concealer is oil-free, so it does not accentuate lines and open pores. However, it requires retouching to set well on the skin after some hours.

Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer Stick

Unboxing: I ordered this concealer because many makeup artists rave about this dupe. Receiving the Neutro gena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer Stick package, I took no time to open it.

I used it over my prime face, smoothly gliding over my skin like butter. It is designed with a unique hydrating core that keeps the skin hydrated all day without cakey finishing. The concealer did not feel greasy, so I did not feel sticky and tacky over my skin.

The formula is smooth, and people with dry skin love this concealer. I wore it for almost 6-7 hours and observed that it slightly transfers or breaks. Moreover, it felt comfortable and breathable over my skin. It is lightweight but not weightless, and it’s like you put an eye cream under your eyes.

I have tried their Healthy Radiant Skin Cream Concealer. The main motive behind using this concealer is to support my favorite brand, Neutrogena. I want to try all their concealers because they use lovely skin ingredients, and the packaging is travel-friendly.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: creamy
  • Coverage: light to medium
  • Finishing: natural
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: stick
  • Recommended uses: hydrated


  • It is lightweight and easily blends on the skin.
  • Amazingly cover the dark circles and spots.
  • Due to the hydrating formula, it sets well without getting flaky.


  • The coverage is sheer and only lasts for a short time.
  • It feels greasy on some people’s skin.

Final Verdict

This concealer dupe has a hydrating formula that is best for everyone, dehydrated skin people. The product is oil-free and non-comedogenic, so it does not accentuate pores. And it was also tested by dermatologists. It amazingly sets onto the skin and allows the skin a silk-like finish. 

Pixi Correction Concentrate Concealer

Unboxing: I was constantly searching for a concealer that also acts as a corrector. I’d heard a lot of Pixi Correction Concentrate Concealer and figured I would take the plunge. I ordered and received my package. Presently the container imitates Benefit Erase Paste somehow, but I do not believe it is similar to it and provides full coverage because that is not the situation.

I applied concealer over my face, which amazingly melted into my skin. The concealer’s texture is creamy, smoothly blends, and stays long. Moreover, the formula of this concealer is buildable with full coverage, so you can build it as you desire.

I noticed the more I applied, the quicker it settled. It likewise does a great job lighting up the under-eye region and concealing dark circles. This concealer is too dry, so ensure you prime or moisturize your face skin before applying it.

 Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: creamy
  • Coverage: full
  • Finishing: natural
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: glass jar


  • Highly pigmented, this concealer helps blurs the imperfections of the face and stays longer.
  • The concealer brightens up the eye area.
  • Pixi concealer is formulated without parabens and is never tested on animals.
  • It is inexpensive and a perfect concealer for concealing.
See also  How to Get Rid of Acne Overnight? Effective Ways


  • This concealer dries out the area which you do not want in the delicate area.
  • It settles into lines and creases.

Final Verdict

This concealer is best for people who want to brighten up and conceal the eye area. Moreover, it goes long on the face. However, this concealer does not give skin hydration, so it accentuates the fine lines and gets cakey instantly if the face does not moisturize. 

Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser

Unboxing: This Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser concealer has been a favorite and hyped product among makeup artists and lovers. This hype made me order this product. It came in a sleek glass tube with a transparent cap. It has a sponge applicator on top of it that got my eye.  

I twisted the applicator, so the concealer was visible on the sponge. Applied it gently under my eyes, and to my amazement, it glided over my skin so smoothly. Once it was blended completely, it looked smooth and even. 

This concealer perfectly hides my imperfections. However, for dark circles, I recommend you use a color corrector before it. Moreover, I used it to highlight my high points, and it did a fab job.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: stick powder
  • Coverage: full
  • Finishing: natural
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: glass tube


  • It is easy to use and allows the skin great coverage.
  • The light texture perfectly blurs imperfections without getting blotchy and cakey.
  • The concealer looks natural and makes my eyes awake and more bright.


  • The concealer takes time when popped on the sponge applicator. 
  • The sponge applicator tip fell off quickly.

Final Verdict

It will be your perfect choice if you want a concealer that gives your skin full coverage. This concealer is lightweight and blends smoothly without leaving any streaks. 

Wet N Wild Photo Focus Concealer

Unboxing: I was too excited when my package came to my door. I quickly ran towards my door and received the parcel. It came in a sleek bottle with a doe foot applicator. Moreover, it has a screw cap that tightly locks so the product does not leak.

The consistency of this concealer was just a little thick and runny. It glides smoothly over my skin and does best in covering all my imperfections, including dark circles. The texture did not feel heavy at all.

It had to stay power. Even though I did not wear it for so long, just for 4-5 hours, it stayed on my skin smoothly and gave it a filter-like finish. Moreover, this concealer did not give any flashbacks. It is not a full-coverage concealer, so you must build it up.

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: Cream
  • Coverage: sheer to medium
  • Finishing: semi-matte
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: glass tube with doe foot applicator


  • It is lightweight yet covers all the imperfections and blemishes.
  • Effortlessly blends into the skin and brightens up the eye area.
  • This concealer does not get patchy and cakey.
  • It is 100% cruelty-free.


  • The formula is not hydrated.
  • It had a thin consistency.

Final Verdict

Happy to know this super amazing concealer so far. The coverage, finish, and consistency is all great. Moreover, it suits every skin type without getting cakey. 


Unboxing: I have had a bucket of concealers, but I wanted to try a new one to know if this works for me. I have hereditary circles that need a full-coverage concealer to hide them properly. Heard about this beauty and ordered it. I received my package and unboxed it. 

It came in a jar container like Benefit Erase Paste. I applied it over my face to know if it worked for me. It camouflaged all my dark circles and eye bags in no time. Additionally, it did not feel sticky on my skin. The consistency was semi-thick and glided effortlessly over my skin.

I also have tried their concealer under the name HD Photography. It was not what I was looking for in a concealer. This concealer did not conceal my imperfections so well. Moreover, it sits on the top, making me look unattractive.

This product is done best on my skin and contains lovely ingredients that enhance your skin’s beauty. The coconut oil and china clay give your skin uniquely tender loving care. 

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: Cream
  • Coverage: full
  • Finishing: semi-matte
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: jar container


  • It glides easily and does an excellent job of blurring dark circles.
  • Stays on the skin for a long time.
  • This concealer is affordable and exceptionally comfortable.
  • The packaging is sturdy and beautiful.
  • It is 100% cruelty-free.


  • It has a thick formula that takes time to blend.
  • Does not work well on severe dark circles.

Final Verdict

NYX concealer gives full coverage, and little goes a long way, so apply it sparingly and build up. Although the formula is thick, it still provides your skin with a natural finish that you love. The longevity is impressive, and it can stay for 6-7 hours.

IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer

Unboxing: I ordered IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer after reading its recommendation from a makeup blogger post. The curiosity about buying this product lies in its claims to hide all the imperfections, including dark circles, hyperpigmentation, broken capillaries, redness, and eye bags. It came in tube packaging.

See also  How to Redeem Sephora Perfume Sampler Online? 6 Steps & Tips

I squeezed out a little amount and used my fingers to pat the concealer. It blended out evenly and gave me a full-coverage look. A little amount of this concealer goes a long, and it did not get into my fine line. 

It blew my mind when I used it, and I found this concealer is very hydrated and has a thick formula, but not matte. Moreover, a little goes a long way. It has a great creamy formula, especially for dry skin people would love it, and it does not give skin a matte finish.

It is formulated with anti-aging properties, vitamins, hyaluronic acid, antioxidants, and hydrolyzed collagen

Key Features and Specifications

  • Consistency: Cream
  • Coverage: full
  • Finishing: natural
  • Skin type: all
  • Package Information: tube
  • Recommended uses: anti-aging


  • Highly pigmented, waterproof concealer that stays all day and provides full coverage.
  • The product squeezes out in thick consistency but blends fantastically.
  • It is not just for hiding dark circles but for all facial imperfections.


  • It gets sticky and tacky over some time.
  • Accentuate into large pores.

Final Verdict

I loved it when I first used it on my skin. It completely hides all the imperfections and makes me look younger. Additionally, it melts into my skin like butter and leaves no residues. The consistency is matte but blends perfectly and beautifully, giving the skin a natural finish.

Buying Guide

Here are some points you should consider before buying a concealer dupe.

Consistency and Coverage

The consistency of any cosmetic product is the definitive, most significant thing. You must know what coverage it provides, so you wear it accordingly. If the consistency is too thick, it does not set and gets cakey; additionally, if it’s runny or watery, it does not blend smoothly and evenly. In the end, only the coverage and consistency of the item shouted out about the product.

Hydration formula

What if the product you choose has a dry or matte finish and makes your skin super blotchy when applied? Indeed, you prefer to avoid your beauty product being like this. Always gets your hands on products that are rich in hydration.


The highly-pigmented product glides smoothly over the skin. It takes no time to blend. If the product has fewer pigments, it does not adhere to the skin. Moreover, the item’s durability and bending depend on product pigments.

Top Brands for Concealer dupes

  • Pixi Correction Concentrate 
  • Maybelline Age Rewind
  • Rimmel
  • Neutrogena 
  • Revlon
  • e.l.f 
  • IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye
  • Urban Decay
  • L’oreal


What is Benefit Erase Paste?

Benefit Erase Paste concealer is concentrated, velvety, and blendable lightens up the skin, and disguises all the imperfections of the skin. It has a groundbreaking formula that helps to camouflage all the signs of exhaust and drain. It comes in three different shades that correct all the face insecurities.

What is the difference between an eye brightener and a concealer?

Eye brighteners are different from concealers as they have a thick formula. It is mainly designed to brighten the eye instead of hiding the dark circles which concealers do. They also come in different formulas for effortless blendings, such as liquid and cream. 

Which color concealer is best for dark circles?

The concealer comes in various colors, but only some of the colors are used to cover dark circles. The green and purple undertone concealers are best for covering blemishes and redness. Use concealer in red, pink, yellow, and orange to camouflage the dark circles. All of this help to even out the skin by covering them perfectly. You can also use this makeup to hide the lazy eye.

How do you get rid of dull under eyes?

Wearing makeup with dull under eyes makes no sense. There have to be some beauty products that are effective in erasing the dullness of the under eyes. If you ask me this question, I recommend you buy concealer with color-correcting properties. 

Applying concealer is as simple as wearing any other beauty product. However, adding this specific beauty product beneath the eyes will not make it bright but also enhance the overall eye makeup look.


Concealing imperfections make you stand out, and if done with the right products, it becomes the cherry on top. In the above article, I pen down the best Benefit Erase Paste dupes that I used and did a fantastic job. Moreover, all the above products are authentic and made with lovely ingredients. Furthermore, I also elaborated on the buying guide that makes it easy while choosing the best dupe.